A 2018 lawsuit against major energy companies was just dismissed. The case could impact future cases seeking to hold big companies, like Exxon and Chevron, accountable for their environmental impacts.
New Lawsuit
Image Credit: Shutterstock / Beautrium
Baltimore filed a lawsuit back in 2018 that aimed to hold energy giants accountable for their role in climate change. The city argued that companies ExxonMobil and Chevron used deceptive marketing techniques to hide the environmental dangers of their products.
The Defendants
Image Credit: Shutterstock / Vincent_Nguyen
Exxon, BP, and Chevron were among the major energy companies in this case. The defendants were primarily accused of misleading the public about the environmental risk associated with their products.
Baltimore’s Claims
Image Credit: Shutterstock / Africa Studio
The lawsuit claimed that the energy companies’ marketing strategies actually increased fossil fuel consumptions. Baltimore claimed that these purchases then contributed to climate change.
Legal Hurdles
Image Credit: Shutterstock / dokurose
The lawsuit faced many different hurdles since its filing, including discussion about whether the case should be brought up in federal or state court. The Supreme Court ultimately decided to let the case proceed at the state level.
Judge Videtta Brown’s Ruling
Image Credit: Shutterstock / photobyphotoboy
This month, Baltimore City Circuit Court Judge Videtta Brown dismissed the lawsuit. This was the first time a case like that has been dismissed by a state court judge.
Legal Basis for the Dismissal
Image Credit: Shutterstock / wavebreakmedia
Judge Brown ruled that the case is beyond the limits of state law. She stated that issues related to global pollution can only be governed by federal law.
Federal vs. State Jurisdiction
Image Credit: Shutterstock / Studio Romantic
One of the key issues in his case was whether it would fall under federal or state jurisdiction. Energy companies wanted federal court, while Baltimore wanted to keep it in state court, which was perceived to be better for the plaintiffs.
Deceptive Marketing Claims
Image Credit: Shutterstock / Freedomz
Baltimore claimed that its case was focused more on the marketing tactics of the companies. However, the Judge ruled that ultimately the city was seeking damages for the climate impact, which is a federally regulated area.
The Clean Air Act
Image Credit: Shutterstock / Evgenii Panov
According to the judge’s decision, the Clean Air Act specifically regulates interstate emissions. Therefore, Baltimore’s claims fall under federal jurisdiction, so state law cannot decide this lawsuit.
Similar Cases Nationwide
Image Credit: Shutterstock / Andrey_Popov
Baltimore’s lawsuit follows a trend of other cities and states wanting to hold energy companies accountable for their environmental impact. Hawaii, Massachusetts, and Colorado courts have seen similar cases.
Previous Dismissals
Image Credit: Shutterstock / Gorodenkoff
Federal courts have dismissed similar lawsuits in the past, including one filed in New York City. The reasoning for these are often that federal law should decide on global pollution claims.
Supreme Court Gets Involved
Image Credit: Shutterstock / lito_lakwatsero
The Supreme Court has had some involvement in cases like these. It recently asked Biden for input on a similar case in Honolulu.
Baltimore’s Response
Image Credit: Shutterstock / Salivanchuk Semen
The Baltimore City Department of Law has been vocal about its intention to appeal the decision. They are persistent that their case focuses specifically on the effects of climate change because of poor marketing practices.
Future Climate Litigation
Image Credit: Shutterstock / smolaw
This dismissal could influence other similar lawsuits, potentially affecting future cases on the state level. It sets a precedent for the federal regulation of global emissions.
Who Decides Environmental Legislation?
Image Credit: Shutterstock / PongWatchara
This case represents the bigger question over who gets to decide cases like these. Future cases at state and federal levels will likely be impacted by this decision when it comes to environmental issues.
Future Environmental Policy
Image Credit: Shutterstock / Phanphen Kaewwannarat
The ruling may impact future environmental policy. This lawsuit dismissal further demonstrates that interstate emissions and climate change discussions should happen at the federal level.
General Consensus
Image Credit: Shutterstock / Rawpixel.com
As with most environmental cases, this dismissal has created many different reactions. While environmental advocates are frustrated, energy companies and their representatives view it as validation.
Potential to Escalate
Image Credit: Shutterstock / Steve Heap
The next steps in the appeal process will determine how strict these legal boundaries hold. The Supreme Court may have to set stricter rules regarding climate change legislation.
Challenges in Climate Policies
Image Credit: Shutterstock / Studio Romantic
Environmental law has experienced a big shift in the recent lawsuit dismissal. It demonstrates the challenges that we as a society face when trying to hold energy companies accountable for climate change.
DeSantis in More Hot Water as Florida Floods, Again
Image Credit: Shutterstock / Andrew Cline
Florida residents are struggling this hurricane season, and many are pointing the finger at a certain Governor. DeSantis in More Hot Water as Florida Floods, Again
J.C. Penney’s Closures Signal the End of an Era in Retail
Image Credit: Shutterstock / Jonathan Weiss
Popular department store, J.C. Penney, has announced the closure of multiple stores across the country. This announcement reflects changes in the retail industry as online shopping becomes more popular. But how will these changes affect consumers and the future of in-store shopping? J.C. Penney’s Closures Signal the End of an Era in Retail
Michigan’s Governor Whitmer Lays Down the Law for HOAs
Image Credit: Shutterstock / Gints Ivuskans
Gretchen Whitmer has just taken on HOAs across Michigan. Who won? Michigan’s Governor Whitmer Lays Down the Law for HOAs
Featured Image Credit: Shutterstock / Thx4Stock team.
The images used are for illustrative purposes only and may not represent the actual people or places mentioned in the article.
